Given the Choice, 78% of Candidates Pick the AI Interviewer: Should You?

Interview Strategies5 min read
Aptivance Career Intelligence · Reviewed by Marquis Harris · Updated November 2026
AI-assisted
Key Takeaways

For most high-volume and entry-level roles, choosing the AI interview is a reasonable bet. In a 70,000-applicant field experiment, candidates interviewed by AI were more likely to get an offer, start the job, and stay in it. Humans still made the final call. Prepare for it like a real interview.

Should I choose the AI interview or wait for a human?

For most candidates applying to high-volume or entry-level roles, choosing the AI interview is a defensible and often advantageous choice. The largest study we have on this points in the AI interview's favor, with one important caveat: a human was always the one making the final hiring decision.

In a natural field experiment by Brian Jabarian and Luca Henkel of the University of Chicago Booth School of Business, 70,000 real job applicants were randomly assigned to be interviewed either by human recruiters or by AI voice agents. Across the board, the AI-led interviews produced better outcomes for candidates: those interviewed by AI were more likely to receive an offer, more likely to start the job, and more likely to still be employed at 30 days and up to four months later. That last point matters, because it suggests the AI interviews were not simply waving people through; the resulting hires actually stuck.

If you are weighing the two options for a customer-service, retail, call-center, or similar high-throughput role, the evidence does not support the instinct that a human interviewer gives you a meaningful edge. In fact, it may be the opposite.

Why do so many candidates already prefer the AI interviewer?

Because when given a genuine choice, most people take it, and the outcomes tend to reward them. In the same Chicago Booth experiment, when applicants were allowed to choose between a human and an AI interviewer, 78% chose the AI, as reported in the SSRN working paper 'Voice AI in Firms: A Natural Field Experiment on Automated Job Interviews.'

There are practical reasons behind that preference. An AI voice interview can usually be scheduled on your terms, often outside normal business hours, without the back-and-forth of matching a recruiter's calendar. It can feel lower-pressure, with no human reactions to read in real time. And it is consistent: every candidate gets the same questions, which removes some of the interpersonal variability that can quietly disadvantage nervous or less-polished speakers.

This is not a fringe experience anymore. According to the Greenhouse 2026 Candidate AI Interview Report, reported by HR Dive, nearly two-thirds of US job seekers say they have already been interviewed by an AI, with that figure sitting at 63% and up 13 percentage points in just six months. The survey covered 2,950 active job seekers across the US, UK, Ireland, Germany, and Australia. Whether or not you choose the AI interview this time, you are likely to encounter one soon, so it is worth getting comfortable with the format.

When should I think twice about the AI interview?

When the role depends heavily on relationship-building, or when the interview itself is prone to technical friction you cannot control. The AI interview is not frictionless, and a share of candidates have real, legitimate objections.

The Chicago Booth experiment is honest about this. In that study, 5% of applicants discontinued the AI interview while it was in progress, and 7% encountered technical glitches that added to their stress. A dropped connection, a microphone that will not cooperate, or an agent that misunderstands your answer can derail an otherwise strong candidate. If you know your internet is unreliable or you are interviewing from a noisy environment, that risk is worth taring seriously.

There is also a strategic trade-off that goes beyond individual nerves. The Greenhouse 2026 Candidate AI Interview Report, via HR Dive, found that 38% of candidates walked away from a hiring process entirely because it included an AI interview, and another 12% said they would. That is a substantial group voting with their feet. If an AI interview signals something to you about how an employer treats people, or if you are senior enough that a conversation with a human is part of your own evaluation of the company, you are entitled to weigh that. Just do so with eyes open about what the outcome data shows, and remember that in most of these processes, declining the AI step often means declining the process.

How do I prepare for an AI voice interview?

Prepare for it exactly as you would a real interview, then add a short technical rehearsal. The AI is screening you against real criteria, and a human will read or act on the result.

Start with the fundamentals. Know the job description well enough to connect your experience to its specific requirements, and have two or three concrete stories ready that show results, not just responsibilities. Because many AI voice interviews ask structured, consistent questions, practicing out loud is especially useful; speak your answers rather than just thinking them, so you get comfortable being concise and clear without a human to nod you along.

Then handle the mechanics that trip people up. Test your microphone and internet connection before you begin. Choose a quiet room where you will not be interrupted. Speak at a natural, steady pace, and do not rush to fill silence, since the agent may still be processing. If the system offers a practice question or a retry, use it. And if you hit a glitch like the 7% in the Chicago Booth study did, stay calm and follow the recovery instructions rather than abandoning the attempt in frustration; the discontinuation rate in that study shows how easy it is to give up a strong application over a fixable hiccup.

Finally, treat the AI interview as the beginning of a conversation, not the end. The research is consistent that humans made the final hiring decisions. Your answers may be reviewed, scored, or summarized for a recruiter, so give responses you would be comfortable having a person read back to you.

The bottom line

If the choice is in front of you and the role is a volume or entry-level position, the evidence currently favors saying yes to the AI interview. It is widely used, candidates overwhelmingly pick it when offered, and the one large field experiment we have ties it to more offers, more job starts, and better retention. Prepare seriously, protect yourself against technical friction, and let the quality of your answers do the rest.

Frequently asked questions

Does the AI actually decide whether I get hired?
In the Chicago Booth field experiment of 70,000 applicants, the final hiring decisions were always made by humans. The AI conducted the interview, but a person acted on the result. Treat your answers as something a recruiter will ultimately read or review.
Is it a red flag if a company uses an AI interviewer?
Not necessarily. AI interviews are now mainstream, with 63% of US job seekers reporting they have been interviewed by one, according to the Greenhouse 2026 Candidate AI Interview Report. That said, 38% of candidates in that same report walked away from a process because it included an AI interview, so it is a personal judgment call based on the role and employer.
What is the biggest mistake people make in AI voice interviews?
Underpreparing because the format feels low-stakes, and then being thrown by technical issues. In the Chicago Booth study, 7% of applicants hit technical glitches and 5% discontinued mid-interview. Test your setup in advance and prepare real answers so a fixable hiccup does not cost you the opportunity.

Sources

  1. Brian Jabarian and Luca Henkel, 'Voice AI in Firms: A Natural Field Experiment on Automated Job Interviews' (University of Chicago Booth), via Chicago Booth Review — 70,000 applicants; AI interviews produced more offers, more job starts, and higher retention at 30 days and up to 4 months (2026-11-13)
  2. Brian Jabarian and Luca Henkel, 'Voice AI in Firms: A Natural Field Experiment on Automated Job Interviews', SSRN working paper — 78% of applicants chose AI when given the choice (2025-08-18 (last revised 2026-09-11))
  3. Brian Jabarian and Luca Henkel, 'Voice AI in Firms: A Natural Field Experiment on Automated Job Interviews', SSRN working paper — 5% of applicants discontinued the AI interview in progress; 7% encountered technical glitches (2025-08-18 (last revised 2026-09-11))
  4. Greenhouse 2026 Candidate AI Interview Report, reported by HR Dive — 63% of US job seekers interviewed by AI, up 13 points in six months; survey n=2,950 (US, UK, Ireland, Germany, Australia) (2026-05-06)
  5. Greenhouse 2026 Candidate AI Interview Report, reported by HR Dive — 38% of candidates walked away from a hiring process because it included an AI interview, and another 12% say they would (2026-05-06)

Ready to put this advice into action?

Before your next interview, take time to tighten your resume and sharpen the two or three stories you will lean on, so your strongest evidence is ready no matter who, or what, is asking the questions.

Get Started Free